Deep Space Nine proved itself separate from the other modern Trek series in “Rules of Engagement” by not relying on a reset button for the ending. Worf really did screw up and destroy a civilian transport. He was fortunate it was empty. “Hard Time’ carries on the theme. When O’Brien is given the memories of twenty years in prison for espionage crimes, they are not only a permanent part of him, but he has to live with the fact he was pushed to the point of murdering his cellmate. So much for enlightened 24th century humans.
Trek is not famous for its subtlety or it fine acting, but “Hard Time” is an exception. From the joyous moment O’Brien sees DS9 again, which to him has been a twenty year gap, to his emotional deterioration as he struggles to regain his old life while eaten up by guilt, we feel every raw emotion vividly. No hamming it up or phoning it in.
I believe Colm Meaney is considered a much more serious actor in the United Kingdom than in the United States. I believe it. I watched the David Tennant and Patrick Stewart version of Hamleton PBS a few nights ago and marveled how Tennant in particular appeared to be holding back emotionally on Doctor Who. What is it about science fiction that convinces otherwise good actors to tie one hand behind their back when performing in it?
“Hard Time” earns high marks from me. Consider that unusual. It is another O’Brien Must Suffer episode, but the best of the bunch. I am usually adverse too stories in which a character is descending ito madness, either.. Often, the plot device is used to excuse lazy writing because nothing has to make sense when the focal character is going bonkers. But when the process is done well, I can appreciate it. “Hard Time” is a tough episodeto watch, but I like it.
I am also glad the original idea was not used. “Hard Time” was originally supposed to be a sequel to TNG’s “Lower Decks” in which it would have been discovered Sito was not killed, but imprisoned by the Cardassians. The episode would have been about her readjusting to freedom. Such a move would have destroyed the emotional impact of both “Lower Decks” and “Hard Time.”
Rating: **** (out of 5)
